Potential Cincinnati Reds Free Agent Target Michael Cuddyer Off the Board Thanks to Qualifying Offer


Sep 27, 2014; Los Angeles, CA, USA; Colorado Rockies right fielder Michael Cuddyer (3) in the dugout after he scored a run in the fourth inning of the game against the Los Angeles Dodgers at Dodger Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Jayne Kamin-Oncea-USA TODAY Sports

In the two-year history of Major League Baseball’s qualifying offer system, no player who has been offered a QO has ever taken his team up on the deal. That will almost surely change in the next week, as the Colorado Rockies have extended the $15.3-million offer to outfielder Michael Cuddyer, reducing by one the number of free agent bats the Cincinnati Reds will have to consider this winter.  

More from Cincinnati Reds

While Cuddyer has had some fine seasons, this qualifying offer is a fairly outrageous development given that

a) He’ll be 36 years old in 2015

b) He played 49 games in 2014

c) He made “just” $10.5 million in 2014

With a career OPS of .813 and maintaining 20+ home run power (when he’s healthy), Cuddyer would have been an attractive one- or two-year pickup for the Reds as they seek to bolster an anemic offensive attack. Realistically, though, he was due for a steep pay DECREASE, rather than a 50% increase.

Even if Cuddyer somehow saw fit to reject the QO from the Rockies — which would be the only possible thing battier than the team’s making the offer in the first place — he would come at the cost of a draft pick for whichever other team signs him. Granted, the Reds were so bad in 2014 that their first-round pick is protected, but even a second-round selection is too much to surrender for Cuddyer at this point.  Especially if he’s going to command more than $15 million.

Baseball is a wacky world, filled with funny money and bro science, but 15 large for Michael Cuddyer in 2014 is a great example of why the Rockies routinely hover near the bottom of the standings.